Transcript 0:00 [on hold music] Welcome, David, to the IoT For All Podcast. Thanks for being here this week. Thank you for having me, Ryan. Yeah, it's great to have you. Looking forward to this conversation. 0:11 But I think, you know, the best thing to do before we get started would be to have you just give a quick introduction about yourself and the company to our audience. So I'm David. 0:18 I'm one of the co-founders and the CEO here at Reelables. 0:21 Reelables, we're all about smart labels, tracking supply chains, inventory, really being able to understand what's actually happening to inventory rather than what's supposed to be happening, and providing that visibility back to our customers. 0:34 Fantastic. And I know we have some interesting topics to talk about today, mainly around supply chain. 0:38 So I, I wanted to just kind of set the stage for our audience and have you maybe give a quick overview of the supply chain industry, kind of where things are, where things have kind of come from, you know, the last number of years. 0:49 We actually talked about supply chain a lot in the early days of this podcast. So just kind of updating our audience on kind of the state of the industry and, and the role you all play in it. 0:56 So when we got started, we started Reelables maybe in end of twenty eighteen. When we started, the industry was really all about tracking high value goods. It was really just getting started. 1:10 Uh, condition monitoring was important for, for certain goods, but it was very expensive to track something from one side of the world to the other side of the world. We're talking hundreds of dollars per shipment. 1:21 And what that meant was the size of the industry was pretty constrained. Um, uh, even today, zero point zero zero one percent of cargo is actively tracked as it moves across the world. 1:34 And so obviously, supply chains have worked for hundreds of years. Things have been, you know, mo-moving for, you know, since the horse and cart, horse and cart was invented. 1:43 But in terms of dealing with the issues that happen, that's basically been a case of, well, it goes wrong and we, we deal with it. We put-- We send emails. We, um... Everything's manual, pretty much. 1:58 Um, even in the case when something goes wrong, so let's say, uh, you receive, uh, a shipment that's short one piece, what's gonna happen is a delivery driver is going to... 2:09 works for the trucking company, will take a photo of it. That'll go back to his or her office. Someone in the office will then probably send an email to the freight forwarder to say, "This happened," 2:20 and you start a completely manual process for what's going on. Another example, one of our customers' cargo got held up at a ground handler because the ground handler was having service issues. 2:30 That created two hundred and fifty emails off the back of that because this shipment was part of a supply chain... as a smartphone launch in the US. So that's, that's kinda how the world works today. 2:43 When you get a, a notification or when your, your online portal says that cargo is, has moved, usually what that means is the truck that it's supposed to be on has turned up. 2:53 It doesn't mean that your cargo's actually, actually there. When DHL, um, have a package or UPS have a package, the only point it gets scanned is when it goes through a sorting facility. 3:05 The rest of the time it'll be stuck on a truck. And so what's actually happening is the tracking that people see day to day is what should have happened. 3:14 It's not based on a scan of their actual cargo where it is right now. It's think that... We think that truck is outside this facility, or we think that it's on a plane. It's not it's actually on a plane and we know that. 3:28 And so what a lot of customers of ours start to get the value out of is knowing where something is. If you know that something's actually landed, you can begin an air import process, um, and you can begin it earlier. 3:41 If you've got cargo that arrives at a warehouse and you know it's at the warehouse, a transportation warehouse, let's say, you know it's there, and you can start to, uh, process that cargo, um, the second it arrives, not four hours later when someone's gone round and scanned all the cargo in that's now in the WMS. 3:59 Those are the types of problems we solve. And so let me ask you about the email thing you brought up. Why does data still flow across supply chains by email? I mean, I feel like that's a... 4:08 There are mu-much more modern ways to do it now. Yeah. So it's, it's really a problem of scale. Um, if you look, if you look at parcels, it, it works, um, and courier services, they generally work really well. 4:19 And you have, uh, one company that owns the entire supply chain end to end, so it's their planes, it's their sorting facilities, it's their fa- it's, it's their distribution, sort of it's their final mile. 4:30 If you look at cargo, if I was to ship here in London, a, a pallet over to, uh, New York, it's going to probably go through at least seven different companies. 4:41 And just in the US, you've got more than a million companies that will handle cargo. And so the idea that you're gonna integrate a million different IT systems together is, is, is challenging. 4:53 Not only that, but the data between those different systems varies enormously. 4:58 You'll have a, a small trucking company that's largely running on Excel, and you'll have, uh, a large trucking firm that's, you know, invested a huge amount in, in IT, is super automated, but they subcontract. 5:10 It's not always gonna be their driver. It's not always gonna be their truck. And so you get that variation in data quality. How's the industry kinda s- tried to solve this? 5:19 I mean, before, I guess, you know, I know a lot of this kinda falls into your all's wheelhouse. 5:23 But just generally speaking, if you look over the last number of years, I'm sure other people have identified this as an issue. So what has been done to attempt to, to solve this problem? 5:30 So I think RFID was, at one point in time, people thought was gonna be the solution. I don't think that's necessarily turned out to be the case. 5:39 I think the big challenges there are how do you join up that sort of i- that infrastructure across everything. 5:44 Then when you look at, uh, the API aggregators, so your Project 44s, your FourKites, they, um, they take on a customer, they explore their supply chain, and they integrate into all the different companies in this, in that supply chain and pull all that data together. 6:00 And that's a good solution for giving you a single pane of glass, but it still suffers from this variation in data quality between all the different players.People recognize there's issues, recognize that this probably leads to a number of problems. 6:14 Um, what are the major errors and uncertainty that are introduced into kind of this legacy way of capturing, monitoring, tracking supply chain data? 6:24 Especially in the IoT space, data is one of the most important pieces of all this. So wh- what is the existing kind of situation? 6:31 What are the problems that that kinda has brought up when it comes to data collection and keeping clean data and accurate data, things like that? 6:37 Generally speaking, if your data-- if you don't, if you have a lot of false positives, so what I mean by that is, um, your system says you've got a problem, but you don't actually have a problem. 6:46 For example, you didn't get a signal to say that your cargo was, um, your, your cargo was on a truck and it, uh, it had advanced to here. Do you do anything about that or do you ignore it? 6:58 Now, if you don't, if you know that actually ten percent of the time you're not gonna get that signal, it's not a signal that you can rely on to say, "Oh, we didn't get that signal, we should investigate. 7:08 We should do something about it." So-- and that's so much of the data in supply chains, that you often have to wait until someone's shouting and saying, "I don't have my thing," before you, you can do anything about it. 7:23 You're often in the dark until that happens because, "Ah well, you know, it's actually quite often the case that it's completely fine, and it would cost us way more to investigate all these instances." 7:33 So you can't automate a response to it. Then on the other side of it, quite often you get data that looks good. So you'll say, "This is on a plane," but actually what happened was it went onto the wrong plane. 7:46 And that plane, and I know for one of our customers, uh, once or twice a year, you'll have a, a ten million dollar shipment going from China, uh, that's supposed to be going to the US full of a whole load of expensive technology, and instead goes to India. 8:04 And, um, no one knows it's in India. It was put on the wrong plane by accident. It was, it was sent to the wrong place. 8:11 And there's a really, really good chance it'll get scrapped before anyone actually realizes that it turned up in India because it does nothing in the customs paperwork. 8:20 It arrives, and no one knows really where it's supposed to be. The information doesn't flow. So that's the thing that doesn't happen often, but is the worst case. 8:28 In other cases, you're dealing with things like cross docks. So you've got a bunch of things that come in, um, they leave, and something gets left behind. 8:37 Often you don't have any visibility as to where these operations are happening, if it's your goods. And so the mitigation to that is to do things like, um, you do full truckloads, even though you've got five pallets. 8:51 Um, and you're, you're paying for the whole truck, but it's because you don't know where these things are gonna, are gonna stop. 8:56 It's because you don't know what's, what can happen when it goes wrong, um, and you don't have a way of fixing it. Once you have that data and you can see it, you're able to do something about it. Makes total sense. 9:07 And then now when it comes to kinda solving a lot of these problems that we've brought up, now I've, I've been... I've seen, I've read, I've heard from people talking about different types of methods. 9:15 Obviously, we've had barcodes for forever. Now vision is kinda coming into the play. We have drones, things like that. And I know on your side, you know, there's IoT smart labels. 9:25 So what, what is going to really power the warehouse of the future and helps solve a lot of these problems? 9:30 And then also, if you look at some of the other technologies that are being incorporated in to try to do the same thing, where do they kinda fall short? So vision's fantastic. It's incredibly cheap to take a picture. 9:42 The, your challenges with vision are that you can only, you can only see what you see, and a drone can't turn a pallet around. A, a drone can't see through, uh, Saran Wrap. Um, 9:57 and so it ha- it has to be, it has to sort of operate around people. It's also very much a facility by facility install, so you install into certain facilities. 10:07 Now that said, I think vision systems are, um, gonna continue to play a big part of, of what's going on. You look at barcodes and RFID. 10:18 So barcodes, RFID, passive Bluetooth technologies, they all have a place, and they're, they're gonna be a big part of the supply chain of the future. 10:24 I do think of them, RFID technologies and passive Bluetooth technologies, very much as a, a milestone-based tracking approach. 10:32 So you're saying, "What goes through this milestone generally heavy on infrastructure," but it, it's like the most efficient barcode scanner you've got. 10:41 Um, you can scan 1,000 things a second, but it's at a particular point in time. The second anything doesn't go through the process, it gets a bit lost. 10:50 Where active technologies like, uh, uh, you know, we, we make a, a cellular label, so it looks like this. It's a, you know, printable super thin label. We make Bluetooth labels that, that look like this. 11:05 We're able to track these types of labels any, uh, you know, in a, in a far more ad hoc manner. 11:11 So we're able to say, "Okay, sure, you didn't come in this door, you, you came in this door," but we still have visibility where you are. You remove something from this shelf to this shelf, we can see that. 11:21 Um, you weren't supposed to move it, that's fine. We, we can update the, your WMS, so you, so that happens. 11:28 You're, you're in a factory and starts moving from one zone to another zone, we can see where, how co- how your work in progress in this instance is moving. Did it get moved to the wrong place? 11:39 Um, there's no bucket for that wrong place, but we can see that it's happened. We can see that it's an exception. We can do something about it. 11:46 You start to get that information, and then when something's out in the wild, so it's moving between different places, you really start to get that visibility without needing to deploy infrastructure, without needing to, to, to, to have those facilities be involved in what's going on. 12:02 So I can slap one of these labels onto a DHL envelope, send it to, send it to my granny-And I can watch it, I can watch it go there. I didn't have to talk. I didn't need to get permission. 12:14 I mean, we have to get permission, obviously, to, to be able to put these devices onto planes, but that happens at a, at a general level. 12:21 But other than that, you just, you get that visibility, and now you can do something about it. And what's the difference between passive and active labels? So a passive label doesn't have a battery. 12:29 It exists, it absorbs energy in some-- it either absorbs or reflects energy in some way, and, uh, then either retransmits or, uh, sends a slightly different reflected signal back so that you can identify it. 12:44 Those technologies, because they have to absorb energy from the, from the air, if they're solar powered, they can get quite a lot of energy. 12:51 But typically, with a lot of these technologies, we're talking about, uh, technologies that absorb radio, radio frequencies, so radio waves, and they have significantly less power. 13:02 So I think at most transmitting ten meters, uh, is where those types of technologies get to, whereas with passive Bluetooth devices, or not, not passive, active Bluetooth devices, you can go for a kilometer. 13:16 And with cellular devices, you can go for many kilometers, and you're going to, um, cellular infrastructure like Verizon cellular. 13:24 Given everything we've, we've spoken about, what does the future of cargo tracking look like? How does it kind of change things when, when, you know, what we're talking about here kind of becomes the default? 13:33 By far the biggest challenge with all of this is what does that ROI look like? Like, am I gonna get a return? For a lot of supply chains, things largely work, which sort of makes sense. Things generally turn up on time. 13:45 At two hundred dollars, you, you very much have to choose what you're gonna track. And even at fifty dollars, you're choosing what you're gonna track. 13:53 Once you start to say it's less than a dollar to track a pallet, I think that's the point at which it becomes a no-brainer. You start to say, "Actually, we're gonna do that for everything." 14:03 We, we, we wanna, we wanna have that visibility. We wanna understand what's going on in global supply chains. Um, we can start to do really clever things once we have that data. 14:12 We can start to reroute things if we want to. We can start to do a whole load of really clever optimizations on top of that. 14:20 And so there's a point at which you go from a world which is default don't track to default track, and that'll be a really exciting period. 14:30 I think as that happens, you're gonna start to see a whole load of other services start to be introduced that are, uh, that are sort of, that are ancillary to that. 14:41 So you start to say, "Okay, well, we've got all this data. What can we do with it? Um, how do we, how can we reduce the cost of our supply chain? How can we make it more sustainable by having less trips? 14:52 How do we avoid, uh, a problem with this ground handler?" So there might be availability on flights, but we know that the ground handling they use is a problem, so maybe let's avoid that. 15:02 We know that there's lots of capacity on this trucking lane. Why don't we ship now when there's a lot of capacity? 15:08 Because we know from hist- we know historically that there's a huge amount of, um, volume that goes through on these days of the week. 15:15 So you start to get to, you s- if once you can see what's going on, you can start making decisions based on that. 15:22 It's very interesting to kind of think about just as a c- even as a consumer, tracking our packages has evolved, and if you really break it down, how outdated some of this might, might actually be. 15:31 If we look at other challenges that you all have kind of come across in your involvement in the supply chain, like all the way, you know, to the manufacturing side of things, y- you know, just, just generally speaking, what are some of the other challenges that you've recognized that really influence the current supply chain that need to be solved in order for us to kind of get to that more ideal future state that we're talking about here? 15:51 There's a big shift that's happened going from sort of paper to digital. 15:56 This is sort of if we go over the last twenty years, people that we work with today remember a world where they were running, they were runners, which is how they started out in the industry, and they got in their car, and they were dr- they were driving documents all over town. 16:10 That's sort of where things have come from. Um, we're fort- fortunately now, things are a lot more digital. We still get an awful lot of documents that are, uh, that are documents rather than, uh, an API. 16:21 So we're downloading PDF and extracting information from PDFs. So that's, that's still very much, uh, a big part of how the industry works. 16:29 Where it's going is to a place where you have this, you have this visibility layer that cuts across everyone, that isn't dependent on who's moving your cargo. 16:39 And that's, that's really powerful because you've got a great supplier that's got a really good visibility, but they, they don't, uh, have a plane that flies on this day. 16:49 And if you really want something to move, that's more important than whether the, your preferred carrier has a plane that flies on that day. You go find someone else. 16:59 But then that breaks down, that breaks down your, your operations and your visibility. And so that's sort of the world we live in. It's moving away from that and having that joined-up piece. 17:10 And then when you go from there, I think so much in logistics is what happened last time, let's do it again this time. This is how we moved last time. We'll do it again this time. 17:20 There might be, there might be new, there might be new players. There might be new players. 17:24 There might be more demand on this day that we move stuff, but, but none of that really comes into, comes into play because you copy the file from last time. That's kind of how you do it. 17:33 How do we move to a place where you've got, actually, we've got a huge amount of data about what's happened historically. We've got a huge amount of data of what's going on right now. 17:44 And then what does the future look like? So that, that to me is the, is the future. 17:49 It's, it's part of this really agentic world that we're g- almost certainly going to move into, where actually how cargo moves is largely decided by a computer. 18:01 But what's really key to being able to achieve that is having reliable data. 18:06 Because if you've got data with huge amounts of error being fed into a system like that, you can't make great decisions, and that's the biggest strength of IoT, that you're able to get really high-quality data.Last thing I want to ask you before I let you go here is just looking at where we are and where we're going, you know, we talked about a lot of great things, but what, what is something that maybe you haven't mentioned that's worth mentioning that you're really excited about to help us kinda get to that state where, where the data is constantly improving, it's getting better, and, you know, we're, we're, we're in a more optimized situation than we are now? 18:36 It pains me to say, but I think so much of this is, is driven by cost. 18:40 And I think that if you went to anyone in a supply chain and said, "For free, you can see where everything is super accurately," there's not a person that would be like, "Yeah, I want that." 18:52 Uh, that, that, that's, that's not a great thing. And so, um, and equally, if you told them it was gonna cost them a million dollars per parcel, they'd say, "Yeah, no thanks." 19:01 So somewhere in between, there's a, there's a point at which everyone says, "I want that." Big part of the industry is gonna be figuring out how to scale that. 19:09 And the, the cost of doing that is not just the cost of like a particular label, but it's that total cost. It's what does it cost to put the label onto something? 19:18 It's what does it cost to have any infrastructure or data services that you need to, to pull that data? What does it cost at all these different s- at all these different stages? 19:27 But there's no doubt in my mind that at some point in the future, cargo is gonna be really well tracked. 19:35 Yeah, I think, um, you know, to your point about cost, this has just been in j- any type of asset tracking use case in IoT for the last ten years that I've been in the space, it's always been come down to that, right? 19:46 Is it worth the cost of what it costs to track it, right? So the more expensive the assets are, yeah, it probably makes sense. You know, you don't mind spending a hundred bucks or whatever it is to track. 19:54 But as you start getting into maybe where there's lots and lots of things to track, if that price can't come down to something that's very low, then it's, it's something that people just easily argue kind of against the idea of tracking it, right? 20:05 So bringing costs down brings these use cases to life. Absolutely. And I think so- I mean, maybe some, some of the other things is it's also that usability. It's like, is, like is it always available? 20:16 So, so many, so much asset tracking today is built upon the idea of reuse of trackers and return logistics. And what happened, and th-that works well in closed loop systems, 20:29 but if you're shipping something to retail, there's no chance you're gonna get that tracker back. 20:35 If you're shipping something abroad, someone needs to collect them up and do all the customs paperwork to s- to send it back. It's, it's all challenging in costs. 20:43 So you need to make the friction of doing the tracking really low as well. Well, well David, thank you so much for taking the time. 20:49 Uh, for our audience who wants to learn more about what you all do, maybe reach out, follow up, touch base in any way, what's the best way they can do that? Best way to get in touch is through our website. 20:57 We have a contact form. We aim to get back to everyone the same day. Well, we really appreciate the time. Um, excited to get this out to our audience. 21:03 You know, we've been following the supply chain space for, for quite a while now, um, and people have been talking about solutions for years. 21:10 So it sounds like, uh, you know, you guys are doing, doing some great stuff over there, which, uh, we'll-- we're excited to kinda stay on top of and, and follow along with your progress. Thank you. Appreciate it. 21:20 [outro music]